Tesla, electric SUVs get poor scores from Consumer Reports

According to Consumer Reports the Tesla Model Y has problems with poorly fitting body panels, leaks and issues with its climate control.
According to Consumer Reports the Tesla Model Y has problems with poorly fitting body panels, leaks and issues with its climate control.
Image: Tesla Inc

Vehicles from Tesla Inc and electric sport utilities from rival brands are among the least reliable models sold in the US, a reflection of the risks of new technology, Consumer Reports said on Thursday.

Consumer Reports, a non-profit organisation that evaluates products and services, said Tesla, the world's most valuable carmaker, ranked 27th out of 28 brands, just ahead of Ford Motor Co's Lincoln brand.

“Electric SUVs as a vehicle category is the absolute bottom in terms of reliability,” Consumer Reports director of vehicle testing Jake Fisher said on Thursday during a presentation to the Detroit Automotive Press Association.

Among electric SUVs, Fisher said Ford Motor Co's Mustang Mach-E “is the only one with above-average reliability”.

Consumer Reports recommends the Tesla Model 3 sedan and rates its reliability as “average”. But Fisher said the rest of Tesla's vehicles are below average.

The popular Model Y SUV, Tesla's best-selling vehicle, has problems with poorly fitting body panels, leaks and issues with its climate control, Fisher said.

The larger Model X SUV “still has problems with the falcon-wing doors”, Fisher said.

Consumer Reports has been critical of Tesla's Autopilot and Full Self Driving automated driving systems. Fisher said Consumer Reports still has concerns that drivers will rely too much on technology that cannot safely take over driving, but that did not factor into the reliability scores.

“Full Self Driving is not full self-driving at all,” Fisher said. “It's a convenience feature.”

Electric vehicle drive systems, or power trains, are not the main source of problems, Fisher said. The issues reported by owners are with other features.

Manufacturers “are using EVs as a technological test bed”, Fisher said. “Those are the things that go wrong.”

The top-ranked brand overall in the survey was Lexus, and eight of the 10 top-scoring brands were Japanese. That continues a long-running trend.

Among brands owned by Detroit automakers, Buick was the only one in the top 10, in fifth place. The Buick Envision, which is assembled in China, was the most reliable compact luxury SUV in the Consumer Reports survey.

Reuters


subscribe

Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments? Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.