Kidnapping attracts up to 15 years in jail, state says in bid put Mdluli in jail

Courts have in the past imposed jail sentences ranging from five years to 15 years for kidnapping convictions, the high court in Johannesburg heard on Friday.

Prosecutor Zaais van Zyl SC made this submission as he argued that former crime intelligence boss Richard Mdluli, 61, and Mthembeni Mthunzi, 60, should be jailed after they were convicted on two counts of kidnapping. They were also convicted of two counts of assault and two counts of assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm.

The matter relates to the assault of Mdluli's customary wife, Tshidi Buthelezi, and her boyfriend, Oupa Ramogibe, in 1998.

Mthunzi accompanied Mdluli to a house in Vosloorus where they also assaulted Alice Manana, forcing her to reveal the whereabouts of Buthelezi and Ramogibe.

The attorney for Mdluli, Ike Motloung, argued that his client should be fined for these offences while attorney for Mthunzi, Sabelo Nobangule, argued for a sentence of correctional supervision.

The probation officers recommended that the two men be sentenced to correctional supervision.

However, Van Zyl said the offences committed by the two former policemen were so serious that a prison sentence was the only appropriate punishment.

The court reserved judgment and will pass sentence on May 18.

Van Zyl said kidnapping was removing someone else’s liberty. He said other crimes happen when someone is kidnapped such as assault and assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm as had happened in this case.

Van Zyl said the crime of kidnapping spanned a wide field, including domestic kidnappings, political kidnappings and stranger kidnappings for ransom.

“Where a firearm is used, the starting point is five years in prison. The upper range goes to 15 to 16 years for someone who is kidnapped and kept for a short time,” Van Zyl said.

He cited the case of Donovan Moodley, who was in 2005 sentenced to 15 years for kidnapping Bond University student Leigh Matthews. Moodley was also sentenced to life for her murder.

“Police officers have a special position in our society. We look up to them for protection. When they become criminals, we need to deal with them decisively,” Van Zyl said.

He also dismissed contentions by Mdluli and Mthunzi that they should not serve a jail term because they were primary caregivers of their minor children.

“This is not the case where children will be left with no primary caregiver. None of the accused are primary caregivers,” Van Zyl said.

He said Mthunzi was described as the co-primary caregiver, while Mdluli spent 40% of the time away from his minor children as he kept two homes.

Van Zyl cited a case in the Constitutional Court which dismissed an appeal by a woman who was sentenced to a custodial sentence for fraud as she claimed she was a primary caregiver of her children.

The court held that she was not the sole parent as the father of her children was a co-resident parent and was willing to take care of them during her incarceration.