We've got news for you.

Register on DispatchLIVE at no cost to receive newsletters, read exclusive articles & more.
Register now

Yesterday’s aid and trade policies won’t solve tomorrow’s problems

Columnist Shada Islam
Columnist Shada Islam

Better late than never. After weeks of neglect, the global spotlight is finally on Covid-19’s devastating social and economic impact on the world’s most vulnerable.

Statements of support, promises of help, and plans for quick aid and debt relief, albeit piecemeal, are welcome.

But yesterday’s policies won’t solve tomorrow’s problems.

The current focus on the immediate emergency is correct, but it must go hand-in-hand with preparations for even tougher days ahead.

In some developing countries, Covid-19 risks wiping out years of hard work and an impressive steady rise in incomes.

With the disruption in global supply chains, trade is slowing. Remittances are declining. Tourism is a memory.

A post-crisis recovery will take time, money and effort.

In the short term, almost everywhere in Asia, Africa and Latin America, creaking health systems must be shored up, and urgently needed testing kits, ventilators and protective clothing for health workers provided.

As more developing countries go into lockdown, factories screech to a standstill and jobs disappear, cash transfers must be made quickly to the poorest to prevent famine and hunger.

Many governments are already increasing domestic spending to help the poor, requiring that the liquidity of financial systems is maintained to keep money flowing to households and small businesses.

There are demands — and promises — of debt relief.

Ethiopia’s Prime Minister and Nobel Peace Prize laureate Abiy Ahmed wants an emergency package worth $150bn (about R2.7-trillion) for Africa to boost health spending, shore up foreign reserves and patch up social safety nets.

If the virus is not defeated in Africa “it will only bounce back to the rest of the world”, he warns.

The IMF-World Bank meeting on Friday will seek a co-ordinated international response to these and other demands.

The European Commission is readying its own initiative for African countries.

This is welcome. But with the economic fallout from Covid-19 expected to cause the loss of up to 25 million jobs — many in the developing world — by the end of 2020, it’s equally urgent to put in place policies to tackle an even grimmer future.

Rebooting the economies of most developing nations won’t be easy.

Old-fashioned aid and trade policies will need a radical rethink. Tired conversations and outdated, often transactional, interactions between rich and poor nations must be refreshed.

The EU, with its expanding network of partners in developing countries, can spearhead the transformation.

But to do so, European institutions, national governments and policymakers must look beyond today’s challenges, short-term victories, petty rivalries and self-absorbed reflexes.

Here are some realities which must stay centre stage in upcoming EU reflections:

  • The shift in Europe’s narratives on aid, development and especially on Africa must be accelerated. The EU’s recent Africa strategy with its focus on a “partnership of equals” is evidence of a changing policy mindset. For too many people, however, helping Africa is still about being charitable. Public support for stronger financial assistance, including debt forgiveness for Africa and other developing countries will only be forthcoming if European leaders demonstrate that our economic future hinges on the prosperity of others.
  • Traditional aid policies will have to include a big financial effort to support the poorest, often in the informal sector, who are now jobless. Providing basic income for those in poor countries — and in rich ones — will become imperative. Money given to people with no strings attached and no administrative hassle is usually well spent, decreases poverty, improves health and allows children from underprivileged families to perform better at school. The financial costs of such an initiative could be as high as about 10% of GDP, but extraordinary times demand extraordinary measures.
  •   Health must become a key feature of EU strategic partnerships and co-operation agreements. Pandemics and health emergencies will continue to challenge global health infrastructure. Investments in national health care capacity along with longer-term preparedness must remain priorities. While defence expenditure is often high, health spending is still depressingly low in many developing countries. EU ‘health partnerships’ must ensure assistance to end governments’ chronic underfunding of health systems.
  • Reform of tax governance and of the multilateral trading system must be accelerated. Governments cannot  keep stalling on decisions needed to combat illicit financial flows, tax evasion, money-laundering and corruption. With dramatic supply and demand shocks in the world economy triggering major trade disruptions, including in services, long-delayed World Trade Organisation reforms have become even more urgent. As European buyers cancel their orders, for instance, Asia’s textile exporters and workers are being hardest hit. They will need financial help but also special ‘corona trade preferences’ through a revamp of the EU’s Generalised System of Preferences (GSP). Negotiations on free trade agreements must also adapt to the emergency.
  • Europe’s obsession with geopolitical competition must be replaced with an effort to work together across ideological barriers. The EU’s recent barbs against so-called 'politics of generosity’, targeting China, Russia, Turkey and others may sound cool but are unhelpful when all hands are needed on deck. The EU is more credible when it speaks of mutual support in tackling Covid-19, co-operation in developing a vaccine and an end to long-running conflicts.

The agenda is ambitious and in a world dominated by “my nation first” policies there will be resistance.

But a pandemic that knows no borders requires global solutions, international co-operation and help-thy-neighbour policies.

Building a strong post-Covid-19 world requires changing yesterday’s policies to tackle tomorrow’s tough problems.

Shada Islam is director of Europe and geopolitics at Friends of Europe, a Brussels-based think-tank

In the public interest, none of our corona virus news coverage will be placed behind our paywall and will be available free for all to read. If you would like to support our mission of delivering award-winning, independent local news, please consider taking out a subscription by clicking here.


Would you like to comment on this article?
Register (it's quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.

Commenting is subject to our house rules.